Consumer complaint against an insurance company after a rejected claim
Legal support for insurance claim rejected, banking disputes and consumer complaints with expert litigation services in India.
- Price
- From Rs 15,000 to prepare the case; hearing fees confirmed in writing
- Forum
- District, State or National Consumer Commission
- Time limit
- Two years from the rejection, Section 69
- Delivery
- Online from Sanpada-Vashi, Navi Mumbai; filing on e-Jagriti
- Law
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Insurance Act, 1938
On this page
- When a consumer complaint against an insurance company is the right route
- Why insurers reject claims, and what answers each ground
- What the litigation service covers
- Papers for a rejected insurance or bank claim
- How the case runs, stage by stage
- Which commission hears your case
- Mistakes that sink rejected claim cases
- Related services
When a consumer complaint against an insurance company is the right route
After a rejection you have three realistic options. The insurance ombudsman is free and quick but has a ceiling on what it can award. You can file a consumer complaint yourself using our consumer complaint drafting service. Or you can have us run the whole case, which is what this page covers.
A full consumer case makes sense when:
- the claim is above what the ombudsman can award;
- the policy is in the name of a company, which the ombudsman does not usually hear;
- the insurer's ground needs to be met with medical records, a surveyor's report or expert opinion;
- you want interest from the date of rejection, compensation and costs;
- you did not accept an ombudsman award and still have time to sue.
Can a business file a consumer case for insurance claim rejection?
Usually, yes. A buyer who uses goods or services for a commercial purpose is not a consumer, and insurers often raise this against shops and factories. But in National Insurance Co. v Harsolia Motors (2023) the Supreme Court held that a policy taken only to protect against loss is not bought for a commercial purpose. So a trader whose stock burnt, or a firm whose insured vehicle was stolen, can generally come to the commission.
Why insurers reject claims, and what answers each ground
| Ground in the rejection letter | What the insurer has to show | What usually answers it |
|---|---|---|
| Non-disclosure of a pre-existing illness | That you knew of the condition, it was material, and you hid it | Treatment records showing the illness began later; for health policies, IRDAI's moratorium, under which a claim cannot be contested for non-disclosure after 60 continuous months of cover, except for proven fraud |
| Non-disclosure in a life policy | The same, within three years of the policy | Section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938: after three years from the policy date, a life policy cannot be questioned on any ground |
| Late intimation of a theft or loss | Real prejudice from the delay | A prompt police complaint. In Gurshinder Singh v Shriram General Insurance (2020) the Supreme Court held that a genuine theft claim cannot be rejected only for delay in telling the insurer |
| Policy exclusion or waiting period | That the exclusion clearly covers the facts | Exclusions are read narrowly and against the insurer that drafted them; the policy wording on the date of the claim matters |
| Surveyor assessed a lower loss | A reasoned survey report | Repair bills and estimates; a survey report is important evidence but not binding on the commission |
The rejection letter fixes the battleground. Insurers are generally held to the grounds they gave, so we answer those grounds head on rather than arguing the whole policy.
What the litigation service covers
- A reading of the policy, the claim file and the rejection letter, with our view on the strength of the case and the right forum.
- A legal notice to the insurer or bank, where one will help.
- The complaint, affidavit, list of dates and indexed documents, filed on e-Jagriti.
- The rejoinder to the insurer's written version, your evidence affidavit, and written arguments.
- Appearance at the hearings before the commission.
- Updates after each hearing, by phone, WhatsApp or email.
The published fee from Rs 15,000 is for preparing the case: reading the papers, the notice, and the complaint ready for filing. What appearances will cost depends on the commission and how many sittings it takes, and we confirm that in writing before you instruct us. Court fee, notary, travel outside Mumbai and Navi Mumbai, appeals and execution proceedings are separate.
Your matter is handled by Adv. Swanand Pandit, an advocate of the High Court of Bombay who also holds the JAIIB banking qualification, or Adv. Ashok Ingle.
Papers for a rejected insurance or bank claim
- Health: the policy schedule and wording for the year of the claim, earlier policies if you have ported, the discharge summary, case papers, bills, cashless denial or query letters, and the final rejection.
- Motor own damage: the policy, registration certificate, driving licence, the surveyor's report, garage estimate and bills, and the police complaint for theft or accident.
- Life: the policy, proposal form, death certificate, medical records of the deceased, the nominee's claim and the repudiation letter.
- Fire or shop policy: the policy, stock registers, invoices, the fire brigade report, the surveyor's report and correspondence.
The proposal form deserves a careful look. Most non-disclosure cases turn on what the agent filled in and whether you signed a blank form, so ask the insurer for a copy if you do not have one.
Consumer complaint against a bank
The same route works for a bank that refuses to put right its own failure. Common examples are a fraudulent debit the bank will not reverse, a wrongly dishonoured cheque, a loan account charged at the wrong rate, and original title deeds not returned after a home loan is closed. On title deeds, RBI directions require banks to release them within 30 days of full repayment and to pay Rs 5,000 for each day of delay after that. For loss from a locker through fire, theft or staff fraud, RBI's locker instructions make the bank liable up to 100 times the annual locker rent.
How the case runs, stage by stage
- Notice. Where useful, a legal notice gives the insurer a last chance and often brings a reconsideration.
- Filing. The complaint is filed online with the court fee. The Act says admission should ordinarily be decided within 21 days.
- Written version. The insurer gets 30 days to reply, extendable by 15 days. The Supreme Court has held that this outer limit cannot be stretched further.
- Rejoinder and evidence. You answer the reply, and both sides file evidence on affidavit with their documents.
- Written arguments and hearing. Each side files a short note of submissions and the commission hears final arguments.
- Order. The commission can award the claim with interest, compensation and costs.
The Act sets a target of three months for a decision, or five where testing is needed. Real timelines are usually longer and vary from one commission to another, so plan on the case running for some time.
After the order
An insurer that wants to appeal to the State Commission must do so within 45 days and deposit half of the amount awarded first, under Section 41. If it neither pays nor appeals, the order is executed like a civil court decree under Section 71. Section 72 adds a penalty for non-compliance: imprisonment from one month to three years, a fine from Rs 25,000 to Rs 1 lakh, or both.
Which commission hears your case
The value of what you paid as consideration decides whether the District, State or National Commission hears the case, under the 2021 jurisdiction rules. Place is more flexible. You can file where you live, so a policyholder does not have to sue at the insurer's head office.
Navi Mumbai sits across two districts, and that decides your District Commission. Vashi, Nerul, Airoli and Belapur fall in Thane district, while Kharghar, Panvel and Ulwe fall in Raigad district. Mumbai residents file before the District Commissions for Mumbai city or Mumbai suburban district, and appeals from all of these go to the Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Mumbai.
The court fee is fixed by slab and paid online when the complaint is filed. There is no stamp duty. If your commission is in another state, many now hear matters by video, and we tell you at the outset how the hearings will be covered.
Mistakes that sink rejected claim cases
- Letting two years pass. Limitation runs from the rejection. Writing to the insurer again and again does not usually restart the clock.
- Signing a discharge voucher as full and final. If you must accept a part payment, say in writing that you accept it under protest.
- Running the ombudsman and the commission together. The ombudsman will not hear a matter that is before a consumer commission, so choose the forum deliberately.
- Ignoring the proposal form. If the agent filled in wrong health details, raise it in the complaint, not for the first time at the hearing.
- Claiming the sum insured instead of the loss. Commissions award the loss proved, so the claim computation has to follow the policy terms.
Related services
Our blog post on what to do when an insurance claim is rejected in India walks through the options before you decide on a case. Our consumer litigation practice page covers disputes beyond insurance and banking. For accounts frozen by a bank or the police, see our frozen bank account service.
Frequently Asked Questions
Still have a question?
Speak with our legal team about your matter with clarity and confidence.
Yes, if you did not accept the ombudsman's award. The award binds the insurer, not the policyholder, so you remain free to file a consumer complaint. Watch the date, though. The two-year limit runs from the insurer's rejection, and time spent before the ombudsman should not be assumed to stop it. We check the limitation position before advising either route.
Read it first. Many vouchers say the payment is in full and final settlement. If you sign that without protest, the insurer will argue the matter is closed. Commissions do look at whether a discharge was signed under pressure, but it is far easier to write to the insurer that you accept the amount under protest, and keep proof that you did.
Yes. A consumer commission can award the claim with interest, usually from the date of rejection or from when the claim should have been paid, together with compensation for harassment and the costs of the case. The amounts have to be asked for in the complaint with a basis, and commissions tend to award reasonable rather than inflated figures.
The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 aims for a decision within three to five months of notice, but most cases take longer, depending on the commission's workload and adjournments. Delay from the insurer's side is limited, because its written reply must come within 45 days at most. A complaint that arrives complete, with the policy wording and medical papers in order, keeps the case moving.
No. When we act for you, we appear at the routine hearings. Your presence may be useful at the final hearing or if the commission asks for it, and many commissions now allow parties to join by video. Your evidence goes in as an affidavit, so you are rarely questioned in the way witnesses are in a civil court.
Two years from the date of rejection, under Section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. A late complaint needs an application explaining the delay, and the commission may or may not accept it. If the insurer has neither rejected nor paid, the cause of action is usually counted from when it should have decided, so do not wait for a final letter that never comes.
Yes, where the bank refuses to reverse a debit you did not authorise and the failure lies with it. RBI's rules on customer liability for unauthorised electronic transactions turn on how quickly you reported the fraud, so the date and proof of your first report matter most. Complain to the bank in writing first and keep its reference number.

Need Legal Assistance?
Get a consultation from our legal team today.
